The old jitterbugs have much better action and noise than the new ones, so I still use old jitterbugs quite a bit.
I also throw a few old creek chubs (pikies, injured minnows), heddon river runts, and south bend bass o renos every now and then.
I don't use any nice ones as that can be kinda pricey.
I used to collect Punkinseeds, but never have fished with one. I may have to give that a shot. I love those old lures
I have a Heddon Punkinseed that I throw sometimes, although I have yet to catch anything with it.