Fun pond fishing! (same fish?)

Went to my gf's local pond this afternoon, tossed a red/black buzzbait around while bank fishing and watching the bluegill when this one takes the bait...

after a couple more casts...I move over to another part of the pond and start casting...they regularly spray herbicide into this pond to control the weeds so there's alot of dead vegetation which keeps getting tangled up in my lure but I manage to catch this next one...poor guy got hooked through the eye =(

They look kinda alike? I'm no expert and I've just recently started taking pictures of my fish (thank god for a good cellphone camera)

I also caught this one awhile back...they all look the same to me =(

now just to catch a fish over 4lbs ....