1: 7.2

2: 6.11

3: 6:15

4: 8.3

The first and the last look the biggest but he is sticking them out HARD. 2 and 4 look the smallest but its the picture angle. They are all pretty close. probably within a pound of eachother and I still say her fish is not the smallest.

CJ, how big are you and how much do you weigh? Can't guess without knowing that!     Was I close with 6'2" 190-200lbs?

No one's close to three of them yet? I guess I was right about the inconsistent guessing.  8-)

Eddie, you can't offend me. Please give it a shot. It'll be fun.

Hawgcaller, your too kind! I told Teria the same thing. The problem that day was she left her shades at the house (rookie mistake), the sun was frying her eyes. We gave her a spare hat to help out.

Okay, I'll help ya'll out a little bit. I am 5' 11" and weigh 150lbs. soakin' wet.

Thanks Korea; missed that.

Okay CJ; based on your size and experts' guesses of my fish....here we go:

1. 4lb 8oz

2. 4lb 5oz

3. 3lb 15oz

4. 4lb 9oz

Here are my guesses:

6.8

5.7

5.2

8.6

Here's my feeble attempt:

1-5.8

2-6.5

3-4.8

4-5.2

I can tell the northern guessers from the southern!

A Rapala!! Jigs!!!!!

5-3

5-12

3-14

4-2

Guessing from pictures can make you look stupid.

Heres my shot

4lbs 10oz

6lbs 2oz

5lbs 8oz

3lbs 14oz

All look between 4-6lbs. The last one looks to have a big mouth, but looks rather skinny.

All this # guessing is like watching a game show,lol

"I'd like to trade this in for what's behind curtain #2 Bob......"

All this # guessing is like watching a game show,lol

"I'd like to trade this in for what's behind curtain #2 Bob......"

It's even more entertaining when you know the answers!

Alright CJ, what's the real numbers?!

I'll give em' tonight at 8:00 pm central time. I'll give ya'll a hint, everybody has missed atleast one fish by more than a pound. Some have missed a fish by as much as 3 lbs.

#1- 6.5

#2- 5.2

#3- 4.5

#4-7.3

I changed #2.  In order of the pictures..

7.2

6.7

6.1

7.8

1- 7.5

2- 6.8

3- 5

4- 6.2

7.0

5.8

4.8

5.0

The third one looks to be around 115lbs...

1. 5 lbs. even

2. 7 lbs. even

3. 3 lbs. 5 oz.

4. 5 lbs. 9 oz.

I took the difference of each guess/fish and added up the total score from the 4 fish. The lowest score won.

gary77, was the closest, on the average, to each fish's weight. Nice "feeble" attempt gary!

PM sent.

CJ

Hey, I was within about a pound on all of them.  Good enough for me!  

Thanks for all the compliments on #3 fish. I sure thought it was bigger than 3lb 5oz. I think the scales were broke!  

Thanks CJ. That was fun.

This was INDEED fun; with the wide variety of guesses and the actual numbers, I feel alot better about my fish now.  

Again; great fish.

Late to the game...

It's much more fun when you have the actual weights to compare guesses!

8-)