https://www.bassresource.com/fishing/catch_and_release.html

Catch And Release Works

Catch And Release Works If you need proof catch and release works, take a look at this monster fish caught by two different anglers.

By

 
Dee Cowgill of Winters, California holds a 13lb 2oz bass caught at Clear Lake on September 8, 1999.

Dee Cowgill of Winters, California holds a 13lb 2oz bass caught at Clear Lake on September 8, 1999.

12 lb 5 oz bass caught and released by the author at Clear Lake, California on September 15, 1999. Did they catch the same bass? We think so!

12 lb 5 oz bass caught and released by the author at Clear Lake, California on September 15, 1999. Did they catch the same bass? We think so!

On September 8, Dee Cowgill caught and released the biggest bass of his life, a 13-pound 2-ounce pig. Dee is a good fishing buddy of mine and one of the best bass fisherman I know. Exactly one week later, while fishing at the same spot on Clear Lake, California, I caught and released my biggest bass to date, a 12-pound 5-ounce lunker.
Now here's the amazing part. If you compare pictures of these two bass, note the following:

  1. Two black pigmentation marks on right cheek.
  2. Split in right pectoral fin.
  3. Ripple in bottom edge of tail.

Nobody who has compared these two photos denies the fact that my buddy Dee and myself caught and released the same bass !!!
   Personally, I have caught and re-caught many fish, which I could tell I had caught before by looking at one type of distinguishing mark or another. But because Dee released the largest bass of his life, I was able to catch and release the largest bass of my life! And because I released it, some other lucky angler might now catch and release the largest bass of his or her life, and so on. We call this our best catch-and-release story.
   One more thing on this, we realize that someone could catch a fish, get a picture taken and then hand it to his buddy on the other side of the boat for more pictures. But note the time of day. Mine in the morning, his is towards the evening. The sky: my picture is smoky from fires up north, his picture is clear blue. You can also see the water is calm in one picture, and not in the other. The weight of fish: When he caught it, it had been on an obvious feeding binge. But after the initial catch, it had definitely chilled out a bit. You can see the difference in weight, all in the belly.
   

Catch and release fish

I took the picture of my 12-5 by myself. All I use is a cheap 35mm camera with a built in timer. It's mounted on a two by four that swivels up from the front bench in my twelve-foot aluminum. Hey, I'm after trophy bass and most of the time I fish by myself. I had to come up with a way to document my catches or people might not believe me. And I can't really blame them. I mean I hear about all kinds of ten pound bass. But you know what, talk is cheap. Show Me The Pictures!
   I really believe that if more guys knew how to do this, they wouldn't feel like they had to drag the fish half way around the lake, or worse yet, kill the fish, to show it off. Catch and release works, folks, but only if you do everything you can to get the fish back into the water.

Editor's note: We received these photos separately from each man, more than a month apart from each other. We've enlarged and examined the photos, looking at details you can't see here. We're convinced this is indeed the same bass. Is this a hoax? We doubt it. They have nothing to gain and all to lose if it were.

 

Grow your fishing skills and improve your angling effectiveness.
Subscribe to the free weekly BassResource newsletter.

Fishing Stories

Read More Fishing Stories