My buddy was fishing these( pumpkin )and he out fished me, and I was fishing the senko. I am not a big Gulp guy but I may need to change! I am not sure if this was a one day wonder! Do you guys like the Sinking Minnow?

in short, nope. I never could get bit on them. They stink, there's very little action, and they stink.

All Gulp products are like Pork Trailers...they dry out and are useless afterwards

I have some in my boat all the time. Specifically, I use them on my bubba drop shot rig when the water is stained to muddy. Then I think that the Gulp scent is a good thing. I have used them as a weightless tx rigged senko imitator. Again, in very stained to muddy water. As the water gets clearer, I think that there are better options available.

I use 'em to locate fish - if there are fish in the area they will bite 'em - then I switch to some other soft plastic 'cause these don't hold up and are kinda pricey.

I like a couple gulp products, but the sinkin minnow aint one of them. No action at all, stiff ass a 10 day old french fry.