I fish 3 ponds in the Canandaigua area, all on private property. I have caught some slobs in all 3 waters. I catch consistently larger fish with jigs and trailers. Find a color that works and you will do well. However, the largest LMB I ever caught out of any of these ponds was on a 1/4 oz Mepps Comet. I can only guess the weight but the owner of the pond told me it was the largest he had ever seen caught out of this particular pond and he has been fishing it for 20+ years. Like I said I can only guess at the weight but it was in the 7lb range. Believe it or not, my daughter caught a 5+ pounder on a piece of HOT DOG out of the same pond. She was about 11 years old and didn't want to bait the hook to catch sunnies. When I stopped at the store to buy her some "bait" she gave me a very odd look but I told her just wait and see. Sure enough, she put a 1" chunk on the hook with a bobber and tossed it into the pond. Less than 30 seconds later she was in her glory trying to reel it in on my custom built ultra light. It was hilarious. But she did catch the largest fish of the day.