Cptndeez64

I have both and have caught more fish with an x-rap. I've only caught 2 fish with the Shad, and they were both times I must have hit the fish right on the head because when it landed in the water, the fish nailed it. Total reaction thing, had nothing to do with the action of the bait. When I've had to work the bait, I've got no fish. Can't say I've used it a ton though. The x-rap darts like crazy, I think it provides a lot of fish-catching ability for the price. It runs a little deeper than the Shad, due to the Shad being a riser. I think my plan for my Shad is to use it when I river fish for Smallies. I think the rise action will keep it from getting caught in the rocks. If you dig around and you'll find deals on Rapalas right now, with Black Friday this week.