Anyone else have issues with these getting torn and taking on water after a few fish?  I super glue them but IMO they shouldn't tear that easily.  My Spro and Mad Maxx frogs hold up much better but I have a hard time never throwing a Scum Frog again because they flat out catch fish.

I use them quite often. They are the #1 frog I throw in lighter vegetation when I'm not chunkin' a Rage Shad. The softer body allows for better hookups but also does tend to wear out quicker and get hung easier. At 1/2 the price of the others you mentioned, and the fact they catch fish for you tells me you should keep using them.

It can be fixed easily with a soldering iron or lighter just becareful