I've had great results with this color. I've caught more bass on this than any other color. From clear to stained water, this works for me.

 

What other brands have a similar color to this and what would it be named from them?

 

Also in Senko, what color or color number is similar to the green pumpkin magic color?

Zoom has the same color, or very similar, with the same name.  If that is particular bait killing it for you, don't change anything!  You don't know exactly  what it is about that worm that  they are keying on.  May be some subtle aspect of it.

Yamamoto 967 Goby is as close as they get.  I have used it and it is a good color.  All of Yamamoto's Green Pumpkin are darker.  

 

 

 

 

The BPS worms are the only ones I use anymore.  They catch lots of fish.  Like said above why change to GY worms if the BPS ones are working?

Zoom trick worms and finesse worms Are my favorites. That color and watermelon magic are my go tos. Anything with magic in the name. I got 4” Senkos in green pumpkin magic, never seen them in the bigger senkos. This color kills it on a wacky rig.