When fishing the 4.8 bullflat I would frequently lose the tail in my first few casts from small bass or bluegill. I'm curious if the 5.8 will be less prone to this issue because the tail is a little bigger and less easy for the gills to grab on to? I know its the same ultra soft plastic but I'm interested if you think this will help. 

It is a little better but not much. The soft plastic is what makes it a great bait, but durability is an issue.