Would like to know which is the better all around caster ?

4600C5 Mag, but any one can be converted to a C5 by changing the level wind.

I've got the C4 Magtrax and it's a pain in the backside. Having the magnetic cast control right where I rest my thumb means I'm constantly, accidentally adjusting the cast control.

The reel is smooth and casts great, but I seldom throw it because the Magtrax feature is so aggravating.