Check out My Old Fishing Tackle.com, found it on a fishing blog that I visit every so often.  The site is new, and isn't anywhere close to Ebay yet, but with enough time, maybe it will be a good alternative.  Note, I am in no way affiliated with this site.  Not trying to spam or break any rules...

http://www.myoldtackle.com/cgi-bin/auction/auction.pl

Interesting site.

I added to my favorites and will check it out from time to time.

Thanks for sharing.  

but there's nothing on there

can't really buy anything when theres nothing to buy... now the baitmonkey is mad...

It's going to be growing according to the guys that started it.  Some of their sold stuff has gone for a lot.  Matt Lures hard perch, some 3:16 stuff... If it tanks, no biggie, but if it grows, then very cool - especially for those that sell lures who are sick of 'FEEbay'...