Love them both, Yamamoto makes a laminate Senko that has both colors in it.   I find myself using the green pumpkin a little more often, as a lot of the water I fish has color to it, when the water is clearer I usually start with the watermelon colors.    A couple of my favorites are the Zoom watermelon and green pumpkin magic.

Watermellon was my favorite until I bought the color Baby Bass..

Baby Bass is now my favorite.

For those with more than 5 colors of any bait, do you guys believe that your access to such variety really helps you catch more fish on the water?

 

Or did you just help the lure company increase their profits?

 

I see guys with hundreds of lures and wonder how often any of them get used on the water. 

If there is a new lure that I am trying, I always tend to pick up green pumpkin before any other colors. It just seems to work the best, in my opinion, in different water clarities. However, I do tend to like a lighter watermelon color for clearer water. 

For those with more than 5 colors of any bait, do you guys believe that your access to such variety really helps you catch more fish on the water?

 

Or did you just help the lure company increase their profits?

 

I see guys with hundreds of lures and wonder how often any of them get used on the water. 

That would be a great new topic. Post it up and I'll respond.