Manns 4" Draggin' Finesse Worm.  I bought all the packs I could get when a store went out of business in my area a few years ago.  Really soft and awesome action.

local bait shop keeper used to make his own 12 " motor oil glitter worms, miss them things like crazy.

The Tru-tungsten worm, and rubber swimbait.

x2 on the Ditto Gator Tail worm

Easy answer for me, Berkley power noodle.

Berkley Powerbait Beast.

 

A-Jay

Can only add that all those listed from Yum would have to be on my list. No clear winner. All are missed. RIP Yum stuff.