Hey everyone

 

Im aware that I asked a similar question in the past, but I needed a bit of clarification on the answer.  I have 2 4000 reels that I use primarily for Inshore and Freshwater. For Inshore I know that they are suitable. But for freshwater, I kind of feel like they may be a bit too big for what I'm doing, then again I could be wrong. I use them in freshwater for peacocks (I live in South FL), largemouth and whatever else lies in the canals that I fish. I use both live bait and lures. Is a 3000 size reel more appropriate for what I am doing?

 

Thanks

P Money

Between the 3000 & 4000 size spinning reels, depending on the manufacturer and which line of reels, there can be an ounce or two difference in weight.

This may affect your rig's 'balance'.  So it really should be taken in to consideration when choosing a reel.

Also, there larger reel will surely have more line capacity, however, casting distance may not be that big of a concern canal fishing.  Either would be fine in that regard.

 

A-Jay 

To a point yes a 3000 Would be more "ideal" for most presentations that people use a spinning reel for. But with that said, I don't think it's crazy talk to spool up 40-50lb braid or 12-14lb mono on a 4000 size reel and throw non-finesse lures such as spinner baits, swimbaits, jigs, Texas rigged worms, carolina rigs etc. As long as your rods are powerful enough to handle these type lures. If you are wanting to use your reels for finesse presentations, such as drop shot, wacky rigged senkos, shakey heads, and weightless worms then I believe they are over powered and a 2000-3000 size reel with 8-10lb mono or 15-25lb braid would be appropriate, as well as a medium Or medium light rod.

I use two 4000 reel here in Iowa. One on a 6ft heavy action rod the other on a 6 6 rod. They are both 6.2 to 1 gear ratio. I like the quick line pickup I get. I use them to fish light lures in heavy weeds. I have some 3000 size and tried them but went back to the 4000. 

Technically they’re gonna work just fine. With a spinning reel most of its job is holding line. The biggest impacts to you are their wight since they’re bigger then required, and excess line capacity. The excess line capacity can be easily overcome by using cheap mono backing. 

 

If your content and they’re workin then no need to replace them. If youre having a particular issue or just really feel like you want to replace them then go ahead and down size. No one here is going to fault you for just wanting new gear and we can help you come up with all sorts of reasons why you need that new Stella 3000. 

 

But you’re not going to lose or miss any fish, or shank any casts because you’re using a 4000size reel.