I hunt Indiana and its Hard to beat a 30-30 or 20 gauge for deer. Both are accurate past 100 yards (I have made farther under perfect conditions) and have great knock down power and are readily available.
Also with the right gun, a barrel change in the 20 gauge and youve got a good clay pigeon, turkey, dove, home defense gun.
My personal suggestions would be something like a Henry lever action 30-30 or a Remington 870 20 gauge or mossberg 500.
Another really really fun route you could take is to get an ar-15 style rifle, buy a 300 blackout upper for deer hunting and use the .223 upper for target shooting and small game like coyote. With the release of two pins the uppers can be switched out. That may be a rabbit hole you dont wanna go down unless you really enjoy shooting/spending money