I'm looking at both of these topwaters but are they redundant as in the same functionality just a different shape? If you had to pick just one which would you pick?

Turns out the Giant is smaller, so they've asked that they all be destroyed...

18 hours ago, Brett's_daddy said:

If you had to pick just one which would you pick?

I've got both in my box, but I'm always throwing the Giant Dog X, probably due to the confidence with that bait. It has always produced.

On 8/3/2019 at 4:56 AM, Harold Scoggins said:

I've got both in my box, but I'm always throwing the Giant Dog X, probably due to the confidence with that bait. It has always produced.

Do they have the same action?

11 minutes ago, Brett's_daddy said:

Do they have the same action?

IMO the Diamante has a more pronounced action and I attribute that to its size.