Pick your favorite game

Halo 3.  CoD4 was awesome, but I beat it way to quick and the replay value just isn't that great to me.  Halo 3 on the otherhand...wow

Did you play COD4 online now thats intense

SOCOM US Navy Seals: Combined Assault  

Halo1 and Halo3. Wasn't impressed as much with Halo2.  Gears of War is fun, but it's not on the same level as Halo.

And for the PC: Tank Plantoon II (old timer, ya, I know)

well i voted guitar hero 3 because out of the list thats the only one ive ever played.

im a big fan of the Manhunt series. (not in a creepy way, i just like all the suspense involved!)

Final Fantasy VII for PS1.

In the NEWer generation, Dragon Quest VIII is an awesome game.

Halo1 and Halo3.  Wasn't impressed as much with Halo2.  Gears of War is fun, but it's not on the same level as Halo.

And for the PC: Tank Plantoon II (old timer, ya, I know)

wow, Glenn. Wasn't expecting that. I agree with your analysis as well.

Orange Box hands down. Half-Life is the best series ever made IMO. And since it comes with Half-Life, Half-Life Episode 1, and Half-Life Episode 2, that is a good deal. Also Portal is a great game but it takes only 2 hours to beat on normal mode. Not sure about Team Fortress 2 because I did not even bother installing it on Steam.

However if you are looking for good multiplayer and fun I would suggest CoD4 Modern Warfare. Single player was way to easy for me even on veteran mode. But multiplayer sure is challenging.  

you left out bioshock

Modern Warfare or I would say go oldschool and say GoldenEye for n64

SOCOM 2. I used to play ALL NIGHT long with my clan. We had so much fun online.

COD will come and go.  Halo will reign forever.

I played COD:4 at a friend's house when he rented it. It was pretty darn sweet.

But I picked halo 3 since I have it. It so freaking awesome! So many different game types and it never boring. Unless the matchmaker keeps giving you the same map over and over. >

Best game of any kind ever is Oregon Trail, by FAR.  Nothing can beat the excitement of that game.  Nothing.

Mass Effect or Halo 3

counter strike: source