I went fishing this weekend and all the fish would tail slap my Pop R but none would actually strike.  Any suggestions or changes I should do. Was fishing around sundown in 84 degree water.  West Point lake, GA

Since there isn't very much information here I will tell you what I think is going on.

You are probably popping it too rapidly. This will cause the fish to miss the popper. When I fish a popper I will slowly pop it. you do not want to herk it to hard but just make a burping sound. I will tug it 3 times just like walking the dog but extremely slow.

I hope this will help you!

I have no opinion on what's going on, but I know for sure that you need to do something different. That could include working the same bait in a different way or using other topwaters.

Or, to put it in the language of the Lindners, your Pop-R had attracting qualities, but lacked triggering qualities. You need a lure or lure action that will do both.

Since there isn't very much information here...

...ummmmmmm...i have to disagree... ;D

Sometimes, if you quickly change size of lure or color you can get them to hit. Also try different retrieve speeds, including just leave it sitting for long pauses.

Try throwing a Fluke or Z-Too to the same area. Start with slow jerking retreive and if nothing, speed up. Fish might want something a little less noisy.

When a fish hits a bait half heartedly, then you need to make a change.  Might be speed, might be color, might be size.  The popper is attracting the fish, just not making them fully commit.  I see this happen on crankbaits a lot.   I get fish on the back hook only or miss a few, then make a color change or speed change and the fish hit harder and take the bait better.

Brad