None of them have the action of the Red Eye Shad IMO. The XcaliberXr50 is my second favorite and then a bunch tied for third.

I already have a 4 red eye shads 3 xcaliber xr75 and a couple aruka shads as well as a couple xcalibur xr50s those who have tried both the hardcore drum and the rattlin vibe by yo zuri which is better?

I like many that other have suggested.  If i was going to byuy 3 I would get 3 different ones so you know what to get when you restock.

My choices would be

Spro aroku shad (Completley shocked nobody mentioned this one)

Xcalibur

Yo-Zuri

I need to stop reading these "What's the best ____________" discussions. They cost me money every time.  >

I hit TW last night and ordered a few more Red Eye Shads, Aruku Shads, Jackall TN/60, Yo-Zuri Hardcore Drums, and a Sebile Flatt Shad.

who have tried both the hardcore drum and the rattlin vibe by yo zuri which is better?

Look at my posts further up.

Don't forget about the Lucky Craft LV500 for deeper cranking. The Red Eye Shad was killer last year too especially on the fall.

I just ordered a few YoZuri and Xcaliber. Thanks guys.  ;D

FWIW I tried a few Spro on several occasions last year and struck out everytime. :'(

The monkey has been unmerciful :'( throughout the years with these baits!!I have most of all that has been talked about here :-[My latest and NEW AND IMPROVED is the Daiwa TD.Have used successfully for a couple of years.All the others are no good no more :