I have used both boats. There are things I like about both. I use a fiberglass boat now, but I dont have anything against aluminum. Years ago my dad and my uncle bought a couple of canoe's. This was in 1972. My dad bought an aluminum and my uncle bought a fiberglass. This many years later my uncles boat has been gone for years, the sun ate it up. My dads aluminum canoe looks today like it did in 1972!