Everything posted by MickD
-
Why leader on braid?
Maybe, but in my experience I've twisted some rods 180 degrees with a significant bend without damaging. I don't prefer the spiral designs, so all of mine are built with the guides on top, so if this were generally true one would think I would have failed at least one by now.
-
Why leader on braid?
Yup, put some force onto a 5 foot length of mono or FC and you'll see this effect. Compare to applying the same force to braid.
-
Minimal rod travel case for 3pc rods
I think you need the 9-6 to 10 foot 4 piece model. But I would call. https://www.reelflyrod.com/tfo-triangle-rod-tube.html?variant_id=16452&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI3fTXj5CX-AIV-UFHAR2_4AMbEAEYASABEgIidPD_BwE
-
Minimal rod travel case for 3pc rods
Mine measures 4 inches on a side, 33 inches long. I carried a 7 foot 3 piece spin rod + a spin rod made from an 8 1/2 foot 4 piece fly blank + 2 8 wt fly rods, 9 foot 4 piece. It's too bad they don't just give the dimensions. I would call a source that carries the different sizes and get the length you know you need and verify it has about 4 inch sides. My spin rods have the tall Fuji guides. 3 piece 7 foot rods are about 30 inches long, I think. 84 / 3 = 28 + the ferrule overlap would give about 30 inches. I know that some of the suggestions you're getting will not carry the spin rods with tall guides, even one of them.
-
Minimal rod travel case for 3pc rods
I like the Temple Fork Triangular case, not too expensive and has worked for many trips. It will hold multiple rods, even when some have tall spin guides like Fuji KLH. Make sure you pack the rods so they don't shift and don't contact each other. https://www.southernreeloutfitters.com/products/triangle-rod-case?variant=13495222632483¤cy=USD&utm_medium=product_sync&utm_source=google&utm_content=sag_organic&utm_campaign=sag_organic&gclid=Cj0KCQjwqPGUBhDwARIsANNwjV6Esavp9PjHcuIh_ZPVFXn29_ttidgdRdjWSJo5vD0ay9mS6-xNzxcaAnlsEALw_wcB While this source doesn't give its length, the case is available in different lengths, check around to find the one that will work for your rods.
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
I think my expert was wrong.
-
(For Me) the worst thing about Braid-line is.......
You evidently have found some braid that is unlike anything I have ever used. Different in just about everything you describe.
-
(For Me) the worst thing about Braid-line is.......
The braid I just took off was old, probably not coated. I think I'll stick with my Suffix mono, not ready to spend over $40 + $18 shipping on X wire. I only find it on E-Bay.
-
(For Me) the worst thing about Braid-line is.......
Hard to believe so many have trouble cutting braid. My biggest issue with braid is something I don't really understand, that of having trouble casting with baitcasters. I cast just fine in the yard, but on the water I think the braid gets heavier when wet and spins off the spool and contacts the posts on the casting reel and screws up the cast. That's the only thing I can figure out. Maybe I have too much on the spool. But I recently solved it by replacing it with Suffix Elite camo braid in 14 pound test, and it works great. Any others experience this with braid? I love braids on spinning, but even there, there are some braids that work well and some do not. There is more difference between different brand braids than most people think.
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
I have read elsewhere, posted by an expert in CCS, that all pennies post 1986 weigh 2.5 grams. Of course you don't even need pennies, they are handy, but all you need is to know the weight. For heavier power rods I have bags of .30 caliber bullets that weigh 300 grams. Whatever one uses, I suggest writing the weight, verified by actual weighing, on the bags. Small scales are available on Amazon for less than $15. Cell phones with a level app and electronic levels are really handy and accurate for measuring the AA, much better than trying to use the CCS angle chart.
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
Can't find my chart, what ERN is 355? thanks
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
If you have a drill press you can easily and cheaply make a rig to turn it into what amounts to a vertical lathe to safely and accurately turn softer materials like cork and EVA. If you need details email me. There are many proposals to turn a drill-driver into a makeshift lathe, but that is very crude compared to what a drill press can do. Just noticed the "doggoned apartment" part of the post. Probably no drill press.
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
The SB841-3 is a very nice blank. I use mine for all kinds of things, from light bonefish jigs to small cranks to finesse. It does a good job an all. It happens to be a surprisingly fast recovery blank having a true natural frequency close to "premium" blanks even though it is RX6. I think your worries are well founded. The RS would be better. I think what you have is a decent drop shot or Ned rig rod (talking the AT ERN 12). A recent drop shot blank from NFC was called "medium" power, and it's ERN is about 12, too. No way would I call a 12 "medium" power.
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
I think you did the right process and got the right answer. I expect that the blank did not weigh 2.2 oz. I got 20 ERN and 82 AA on that blank.
-
2nd Rod Build (lightweight, finesse, spin)
Something is funny about the CCS measurments or the blank itself- 12 is very light power and 73 is moderate action, not what most would call "mag bass." ?? The CCS numbers are static numbers and the addition of guides and grips/etc will not affect them. You can sand down any blank to make it matte, but it will probably end up a blacker color. You have to be careful not to go too far with the sanding. I would leave it alone and build another rod with matte blank. One can never have too many rods. Like women's shoes and purses. Each has its place and reason for being. Regarding gluing seats, this is the exact wrong place to worry about weight. Most factory rod failures, in my experience, are due to insufficient epoxy between the seat or grip and the blank. I never skimp and have never had a failure. The weight here will be very minor and will not affect the power or action or recovery time of the rod. Weight is important out on the blank, but not much at the butt. My way of locking is to wrap the last 3 wraps aroung the eye of the guide, then do a pull through. At times I do use wraps on the other side of the junction of the eye and foot, depends on whether I can make them cleanly with no gaps or not. Depends somewhat on the design of the guide and whether the blocking wraps can be done without gapping. Hard to explain. To make a 2.2 ounce blank into a 3 oz rod is certainly surprising. I think the skeleton seat must be very light. The guides are probably about .15, cork about .5. Doesn't leave much room for the seat and wraps/epoxy/ (but that will be minor, probably .15 or less, I think) I doubt if that light a power blank actually weighs 2.2. The Rainshadow blank is much more powerful and weighs 2.2 if I remember right. Welcome to the club!
-
Alberto knot question: knot cuts through leader
We are on the same page. I started adding the half hitches after a few mystery failures, unravelling, based on my experience of never being able to untangle a tight knot on my braid line. I figured if I cannot get one loose, maybe Mother Nature cannot either.
-
Alberto knot question: knot cuts through leader
but the danger is more from coming untied than breaking. That is the problem I was now and then having, but didn't understand it. Adding the two tightly set half hitches solves it and doesn't make the knot any bigger.
-
Alberto knot question: knot cuts through leader
I have had trouble with the Alberto when I don't really tighten it hard. I now tighten it very tightly, both pulling on the working lines and especially the leader tag end to tightly close its loop. I've added two half hitches of the braid tag end to prevent unravelling, which occasionally happened even though I was sure I was tying correctly. But I use quality FC, and have never had a failure like the OP describes. It could be our different definitions of what is "tight," but I think recommending not setting the knot very tightly is inviting unravelling.
-
Alberto knot question: knot cuts through leader
If you are wetting the knot and tying it well then I suspect fragile FC is the issue. Change to mono or a leader grade FC. I use Hitena fly tippet material and have never had what you describe happen. I believe leader grade FC is tougher and it usually is stiffer, so tangles less with some lures like blades.
-
Can overfishing "kill" a spot?
Does a duck have webbed feet?
-
Packing Rods to Move
Make sure the rods cannot move in the tubes. If a rod moves and jams the tip into the end of the tube, it likely will break.
-
Looking to build the lightest spinning rod possible
Similarly, threads wraps need only be a few wraps past the foot of the guide. This is especially important out on the blank, not as big a deal near the butt.
-
Best 3000 size spinning reel for $100 or less?
"Are you a cheapskate who demands that your spinners have an anti reverse switch?" Be sure what you choose has a switch. Many newer models are eliminating them. Every Daiwa reel, spin or cast, that I have is an excellent reel.
-
Looking to build the lightest spinning rod possible
Let us know how you like fishing it. (I already know the answer, having one almost like this one.)
-
Drag Setting Method-Pro or Con
This makes me recall the guy who fished bonefish in the Bahamas for his first time. He had an elaborate, precise, way of setting the drag to acheive a percentage of the breaking strength of his leader. A guide took his rod, pulled to test the drag, and told him it was too tight, would cost him fish. Of course the guy was confident in his method and didn't believe a simple pull on the line could be better, so he kept his setting. After losing the first two or three fish he let the guide set the drag properly for the conditions. And all was well. Except for a bruised ego. There is no need for elaborate methods. There is need for reasonably good judgment based on common sense and some experience, as has been suggested above.