I am looking for a suspending lure that has the same action as the Rapala Xrap Suspending that do not cost 7 and 8 bucks like the Xrap does. Does anyone know anyother brands that have immitated the Xrap and is selling them cheaper?

Nothing has the same action as an X - rap, you can't replace them.

You won't find anything cheaper, not with similar performance.   Most of the better jerk baits are even more pricey.  I switched to braid fishing them from shore - a lot less snap offs from the snags.

When you are looking for something that specific, you will probably have to buy the original. I think the quality of the Rapala baits at that price make them the best bargain on the market.

Excellent lure, great value!

8-)

Nothing will replace the Xrap... I know they are expensive, but they are WELL worth every penny. I've started putting dressed trebles on some other jerks and cranks and they do seem to improve strikes a little. But they just don't have the same action!

Sometimes you just have to bite the bullet and spend a little money.

Ok thank you for all the advice I will just stick with buyin the xrap. I fish very clear waters what color should I look at? The original shad works in stained but it doesnt seem to in clear water.

Silver Blue

http://www.cabelas.com/p-0030669119074a.shtml

8-)

at 7-8 dollars, the x-rap IS the replacement for the more expensive baits, and is well worth the cost.

I like the olive green and anything darker in color. I find that the white is too strong and usually doesn't get bit.

I think this is one of the most unanimous answers I have seen in a while.. I'd say I agree, x-raps are worth every penny. I haven't found anything better for the buck.

Another piece of info that i put in my color selection is I have seen the bass chase and eat the bluegill in the pond but I see the shad just swim around the bass with no problem.

In clear water just match the natural forage as close as you can.