Which one is a better all around reel?

Whichever one feels better to you. They're both good reels so pick the one you prefer if you can get somewhere you can handle both. What I like in a reel and what you like in a reel are potentially very different. It even comes down to things not often thought of, like comfort. I can't fish some of the small reels that other guys love, because they don't fit in my hands well and end up causing me discomfort. Or a reel like the Revos, they're too long and I can't grip them well, so I don't own any even though many others like them.

^ Exactly on the $$!

Id buy which ever one is cheaper. Both are amazing reels. At that range also look into the okuma helios