Mine would have to be either the Horny Toad or Buzzfrog in Green Pumpkin.

Gamber Cane Toad (any white-bellied pattern)

Although I like the horny toad for "subsurface" work,

the Cane Toad can be cranked very slooowly without sinking,

and those lobed feet make quite a commotion

Roger

i agree ,,, the cane toad seems to be the one ..... now i also like the zoom toad and the ribbit but if i could olny pick one it would be the cane toad ....

I went with the Zoom toad.  I have had the best luck with it so far.

I like the cane toad but it is only good for a fish or 2.  The Black Magic brand from Gander Mtn. seem to hold up the best.

My box has 90% black Horny Toads and 10% white Horny Toads.

I've only tried the horny toad, and I haven't had much luck with them. I think I'm going to try the cane toad now.

I voted for the Horny Toad, but the Cane toad is a REAL close second...  The horny toad is more versatile in my opinion.

A white Horny Toad is my choice.

gotta go for the original,my votes in for the stanley ribbit ,i use it in watermelon gold flake