I bought the 5" one.  I like the action, but have not caught a bass on it yet.

It seems to want to come up to the surface & wake quite quickly.  Do you guys experience this too?

How are you fishing this lure, besides a steady straight retrieve?

Do you think adding a feathered treble will make this bait more appealing to a bass?

I've got a couple of them and like them. Fish it just below the surface reeling and stopping and twitching. Works good.

They have great action, I have caught bass, pike, and trout on them. I just wish they would sink deeper. I might try putting some suspenstrips or stick on lead putty on them.

do you guys think this will be a good bait in the fall????

Yes.  

I had the same problem when i first got my Sebile Magic swimmer. try retrieving it a little slower or doin a stop and go kind of retrieve

i've caught like one or two bass on it but its probably not the best best for where i live in this current season.

This kid GAVE me one he said it didnt work I changed the hooks (he put a sure set on the back) worked like new.  ;D