In the Northeast, it has recently become a big trend to throw big swimbaits in ponds that are fed by sea-run herring. Looking into this more I have found that this is mainly done with big casting reels. However, being near the coast, big saltwater spinning rods are the norm here. My question is is there any reason why these big swimbaits cannot be thrown on spinning rods that are rated saltwater-spec (1-4 oz)? Just trying to declutter my rod selection

I don't see a problem using inshore rods for big swimbaits.

 

Just make sure you got a reel that can handle it - a 4000 or 5000 sounds about right to me.

i throw big 6-8” boot tails on a mojo inshore spinning rod for stripers here in CT tidal rivers and in the long island sound. i don’t see why you wouldn’t be able to for freshwater bass either 

29 minutes ago, bass.slayer69 said:

My question is is there any reason why these big swimbaits cannot be thrown on spinning rods that are rated saltwater-spec (1-4 oz)?

No, except for it kinda sucks doing it. My brother tried several reels up to a Daiwa BG 4000, which is massive for the size class, and various inshore rods rated for the baits he wished to use. But if you're not comfortable using a baitcaster you'll make it work I suppose.

If the reel can cast the line needed and rod handle the lure weight, the only down side would be the combo weight may limit your ability to cast for hours.

Tom

35 minutes ago, WRB said:

the only down side would be the combo weight may limit your ability to cast for hours.

And another would be that larger spinning reels like the BG 4000 pick up 40" per crank. This fact added to the overall weight issue you mentioned makes it all quite ponderous.