Not a typical top water lure but I would try a fluke. You could work it on top but you could also let it fall a foot or two. Good luck 

late to the party here! but 100% percent

 

i will throw a lightweight frog that floats all the time.  has to have front and rear legs no skirt no popper.

 

just throw it on shore or logs and hop it into the water! and swim it back to your shore!  it will get destroyed often so have multiples ready and have a crankbait ready to follow up blowups that dont hookup.

https://www.lurenet.com/heddon-zara-puppy

Black Shiner

 

For numbers this will be your most productive hard bait.

On 10/3/2022 at 11:44 AM, looking45 said:

Not a typical top water lure but I would try a fluke. You could work it on top but you could also let it fall a foot or two. Good luck 

z-man's flukes float, or very nearly so depending on the size of the hook.