Who would you rather have the QB of your team???

I'm personally a Brady fan.  He has got IT, and from what I have seen he just seems to be a better overall leader.

It will be interesting to see what everyone thinks.

Look, I am a Steelers fan through and through....but you just cant argue with three super bowl rings for brady. Considering all the adversity that team goes through w/ injuries and losing players, you are right....he has IT!

That's a tough call.  I like both of them.  I do think Brady has had better teams around him and that Manning has made a slightly bigger difference to his respective team so I would have to lean towards Manning if it were my team.  But it's hard to argue with the rings.... even if you have had a defense!

Thats like pickin between a red porshe and a blue porshe.....they are both great talents...I'm partial to Manning only because of the ties to The Univ of Tenn. I really think that Brady is in a better orginization with a better coach which is IMHO why he has the rings and Peyton doesn't.

Brady. Best QB in the league.

I'd go with Manning. Yes, Brady has who-knows-how-many superbowls under his belt, but Manning seems to have more experiance.

I'll take Peyton for the first 8 games and then switch to Brady for the last 8 plus the playoffs and Super Bowl.Hows that? ;D

I'll take Tom Brady and their defense.

I will also take the running game of the Patriots, if they can eat clock up, they keep Peyton on the sidelines.

Keeping Peyton on the sidelines is the best defense, and that doesn't always mean he loses.

Matt.

Peyton!!!!

But his Brother Eli would be cool too