Mine is a Rapala Super Shad Rap

Mine is the Bull Dawg in white and blue.  I use the 9 inch version.  (No comments from Muddy please)   ;D hahaha.  

I've never caught anything on it though.  Still, it's my favorite to fish.  

I also like to fish depth raiders.  Again, nothing though.  

What I HATE to fish, in-line spinners.  What have I caught my two on, in-line spinners.  Disgraceful.

Oh, don't get me going.  I feel a fever running in my viens.  I'm gonna have to take a few sick days and fly up north to visit some relatives if anymore of this musky stuff comes up.  

Cheers.

Top Raider or other similar topwaters are my fav to fish, but have caught the most on the old stand by black/chrome bucktail.

Wendel's Musky Harrasser.

In-line Bucktail Spinner (black & orange)

Roger

Too many choices to pick from. On the Potomac my personal favorite is Dunwright crankbaits (Black/Orange) number one producer.

Black & Orange in-line, or a 9" bulldawg in the sucker color.

How did I know MskSlyr was going to post on this one?  ;D

I would say my favorite is the one that caught my current PB, Bucher Top Raider in Baby Loon.

Believers 9", Super Shad Raps, and Bucktails.

Falcon

What color in the super shad raps do you find most effective.  I picked up a firetiger for 6 bucks not long ago.