Skip to content

Opinions-Did I Buy The Right Rod For These Purposes

Featured Replies

Although I am pretty confident in my choice, I still like to hear insight from others with experience.

Today I picked up a 6'3" M/XF St. Croix Avid. I matched it up to a 30 size Pflueger Medalist reel. 80% of the time I will be using it for 3/8-1/2 oz "safety pin" spinnerbaits and weedless swimbaits. However, I also needed a rod that can accomodate 1/4 oz inline spinners like rooster tails when I am out for brown/rainbow trout as well as the occasional need for a walleye jigging rod. What do you think? Should this rod handle these tasks well?

Nice outfit, should work. Take it out and fish it. If it is comfortable, and it does what you want it to do, then you got a winner.

  • Super User

I think yes. A rod like that does well on many different techniques, i.e., medium power, fast action.

  • Super User

That rod will do those techniques fine.

  • Super User

I might have gone with a slightly longer rod but on the other hand there isn't much there that feels as awesome as wielding a rod as if it were a light saber. Other than that and that detail is minor and not a show stopper, I think you made a solid choice.

i have that same rod (with a pflueger arbor 7430 on it) and its a great rod, while i only use it for vertical jigging for walleyes, and occasionally pitching jigs as well (have a 6'9" mlxf ltb for pitching, mostly, and that works as a good vertical rod too) its very sensitive, light, and casts pretty well for its length. it has a short handle so the portion of the rod from reel to tip is decently long for its length.

i like a rod with a little more give for spinnerbaits and swimbaits (i dont rig weedless usually, its on a jighead.) so have been using my fenwick hmg 7' med/modfast, but u ised a 6'6" mlf hmf (and fenwicks fast in this rod is closer to xf than f) this spring for spinnerbaits and swimbaits and it works great, so i dont think you will have a problem with the croix.

on a side note, i know a lot of people on here will likely laugh at throwing 1/2oz spinnerbaits on a medium light spinning rod, but it worked very well, to the point i dont recall losing any fish on it.

I might have gone with a slightly longer rod but on the other hand there isn't much there that feels as awesome as wielding a rod as if it were a light saber. Other than that and that detail is minor and not a show stopper, I think you made a solid choice.

Would a Avid 6'6" med. fast, have been a better choice for the OP's requirements? I was looking at the same 6'3" rod but now I am thinking 6'6". One is "fast" and the other is "x-fast".

  • Super User

I don't know if better is the right word. For the OP, if he's fishing close quarters more than not, the rod would be a sound choice. Like I said it would be like wielding a light saber, lol. 6'6" to just over 7' seems to be the general consensus for the length of a "bass" rod, but that is not set in stone. As for fast vs x-fast, I've never used an x-fast rod so I don't know how the two differ and even here, I have never seen any posts that could clearly describe to me in a way I can understand how the two differ enough to make a serious difference in either setting the hook or rod castibility.

  • Author

I don't know if better is the right word. For the OP, if he's fishing close quarters more than not, the rod would be a sound choice. Like I said it would be like wielding a light saber, lol. 6'6" to just over 7' seems to be the general consensus for the length of a "bass" rod, but that is not set in stone. As for fast vs x-fast, I've never used an x-fast rod so I don't know how the two differ and even here, I have never seen any posts that could clearly describe to me in a way I can understand how the two differ enough to make a serious difference in either setting the hook or rod castibility.

It seems from my experience that xf tips will give you a little more casting distance with light lures, and definatly improve hook set power. I was originally looking to get a 6'6" M/F avid ( rated at 1/4-5/8 oz lures) but when I saw the weight rating for this rod (1/8-1/2 oz lures) it seemed it might be a better choice for my 1/4 oz inline spinner baits. I am hoping the xf tip on a 6'3" rod keeps casting distances comperable to the fast tip with 3 extra inches. Looks like I will see tomorrow morning. ;-)

  • Super User

I have that rod. The 6-6 is only about an inch and a half longer from the reel seat. It'll work fine for what you want, though 1/2 oz. is pushing the upper limits.

My favorite jig, live bait weight forward spinner, and live crawler harness outfit on Lake Erie is that same setup, almost, I use LES63MXF and a 2500 stradic, that rig is also killer for workin tubes for Smallies ! The 6'8" mxf is excellent also but I love that smaller combat tactic feel the 6'3" gives you, I have landed 6 lbs Smallies and over 8lbs Walleye on mine and love the battle, I have never had a problem throwing as heavy as 3/4 oz lures with mine, as the XF action handle a little heavier lure well also, d**n I love that outfit! I think it is the most versatile for the fineness fisherman, which I enjoy more than horsing them!

That setup is a stellar choice in my book!! I wish you many years of memorable battles, enjoy!!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.