What have you had the most success on?

Gambler Cane Toad

Fished like a soft buzzbait, this toad stays on top at slow speeds (dyn-O-mite)

The cane toad has been doing extremely well in Florida bass tournaments (nationally too).

Roger

I have been using the manns hardnose lately and seem to be doing well in the past I have had luck on the yums as well.

STANLEY RIBBIT!!!!!  

I can only speak of this part of Louisiana but the time of year dictates which type I use.  Early (May to Early June) I use the horny toad exclusively.  The reason is it is absolutely dominates during the shad spawn that occurs during that time.  The feet make a flipping sound identical to that of shad flipping during the spawning ritual.  Now on the other hand during the dog days when its scorching I will only throw the ribbit.  This bait was designed originally by reaction lures, a local bait company here in NE Louisiana.  It was later sold to Stanley.  It is very similar to a buzzbait but far more weedless.  These are the only two brands you need.  They will cover all your bases for this genre of baits.

Zoom Horny Toads and YUM Buzzfrogs.

i use a few .... my go to frogs are the cane toad ,,,, ribbit ,,, and horney toad .... these are the frogs i like on top ,,,, now i do like the sizmic toad as a jig trailer when swimming a jig ....

I have had some success on the Scum Frog. In chartreuse color with white and chart. skirt

Zoom horny toad and the cane toad.  Both have worked well.