bulldog1935
Super User
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Forum: Fishing Rods, Reels, Line, and Knots
Everything posted by bulldog1935
-
Anyone have experience with telescopic casting rods?
Absolutely agree with @QED on Daiwa as a recommended choice. The Japanese are big on multipiece and telescoping rods, because they travel everywhere by train, and want to save face in tight spaces. My only experience is a high-grade Smith stream rod (my buddy Lou has a Daiwa BBB ML spinner), and the Smith is one of the best rods I've ever cast in any configuration. mine is for bike-fishing hill country county road crossings where you're not allowed to park a car
-
whats the best long casting reel?
there's logic to @WVU-SCPA linear mag brake choice. (likewise, my ZPI Alcance above) If his start-up cast is smooth enough to get past start-up jerk backlash with that much weight, the simple linear mag brake will get a longer cast than a complicated DC system. Super Duty G continues to blind me with its long, reliable casts - the clean spool flange with no added mass or complications is part of that picture. (but it won't cast to distance of the Alcance Mg spool)
-
whats the best long casting reel?
which again is off topic. The OP asked what reels cast farther, and if you take any reel, you can double the cast distance or cut it in half by changing the settings on it. If you look at it from design, you can increase the cast distance by reducing spool mass and inertia, so that everything about the spool and reel casting brake system works better. That's the velocity end of the cast curve and pretty much equates to rod length. From simple ballistics, very 20% increase in initial velocity doubles cast distance. You can get the same 20% by increasing the rod length 20% or by increasing the spool speed 20%. Every erg of work you don't have to subtract from the spool with brakes extends the cast distance. Tournament casters know that loaded line mass is part of the equation, and never load their spools with more a prayer's length of extra line, to keep the loaded spool mass down. They only plan to cast it once - they don't thumb at the end of their cast and don't care about end-cast backlash. Fishermen need a more reliable system, because they would like to cast over and over.
-
whats the best long casting reel?
The OP's question was really simple and doesn't require extrapolation, interpretation, and especially not pontification - especially when they're all erroneous. Ambassadeurs were picked by champion distance casters because they were the only reels available with ball bearing spools, and easy to modify to remove the extraneous parts. Still not related to the OP's simple question, which deserves a fair answer. The reason one would want a fishing reel that casts great distance is because it reduces the effort and increases the reliability when casting to actual fishing distance.
-
whats the best long casting reel?
@Jay9527 everything is going to cast farther than dc, by definition. DC applies brakes 1000 /s Lightweight (Mg) spool (or honeycomb alloy) have such low inertia, they respond to less brake force for longer cast. Casting is ballistic - speed is everything in distance.
-
Small rant - trout comes in tomorrow (PA)
The all-time slime demon is gafftopsail catfish on the coast. While the meat is quite good, handling these fish and dealing with their plastic slime on everything (your line, your rod) is a horror.
-
whats the best long casting reel?
Have to agree with Abu CT for ultimate distance - even better with Avail microcast spool (2012 world champion), braid and Avail internal mag brake. For my fishing, the greatest practical 1/4-oz distance is ZPI Alcance - magnesium spool, titanium spindle, and tuned mag brake cam. For the 3/4 oz, I think you'd be hard-pressed to beat Steez SV TW or Metanium MGL.
-
Post a photo a day!
Blown out over the weekend. Though the fishing was a bust, the RV'ing was still fun, still enjoyed the paddling, and got our seafood (and fishbowl Rita) fix
-
Small rant - trout comes in tomorrow (PA)
People who are after the trout are missing the point of trout fishing. The good news is most of those people stack up at the stocking points. The point of trout fishing is busting far away from the crowds to where the trout don't know the difference between stocked and native. For me on a month project in Kingsport, TN, it was Beaverdam Creek. Had to drive through miles of VA where the river was wall to wall trout stamps. As soon as I crossed the state line back into TN, it was all mine. The trout I'll never forget required laying across a leaning tree and daubing the fly just upstream from her.
-
Other Species Latest Catch Pics Thread
From college in Nashville, would visit my grandfather on his farm in McNairy Co. Picwick was close, and remember April days with a fly rod below the dam. Could sit on the ramp and troll the fly rod in the generator eddy - and catch Tennessee tarpon at the rate of 100/hr.
-
Post a photo a day!
kitties like mudflaps
-
Fly fishing
obstinate can definitely be a "quality" of fly fishermen. While long brave casts are rarely useful, they most often put down fish, and beginning fly fishermen become hung up on casting. Catching fewer fish does not mean it's time to cast more - catching fewer fish is usually the result of casting more. Adding to the skill set, reading water is important, and that's where I've always had a natural skill (not that thinking like a fish is a challenge). The goal of sight-fishing is catching a fish every cast. I will stand by my statement and results. Alaska in September - they were all this size gorged on salmon flesh and eggs - one every 3rd cast. Had to kick salmon carcasses aside to step into the river, and the black slate bottom was pink with salmon eggs. More proof about Gary Borger's trout IQ data - whatever could entice these fish to take your fly under those conditions. 24 of these was enough to call the day, and send me to the firepit for a cigar and cognac.
-
Fly fishing
Two places where fly rod shines - moving water, and sight-fishing. While moving water includes tide passes, I keep telling my friends salt finesse makes salt fly rod obsolete. If you're not catching a fish every 3rd cast on a fly rod, you're using it wrong. Stealth is the most important skill. Been fly fishing since 1974, have caught well over 100 species on fly rod, and fished on national TV twice. Used to run a fly fishing life group from church, and guided 4 to 14 friends every other weekend. Ran out of things to prove decades ago. Thirty years ago, I became so jaded catching fish-after-fish on graphite and disc drag, wondering why I was harassing the fish - many fly fishermen reach this point, clip the hooks on their flies and count coup. I made the switch to old cane rods and click-pawl reels and again found the oh-crap-what-am-I-going-to-do-now feeling I'm on the board of GRTU, and run Trout in the Classroom for Texas Adding to what Cap'n Phil said below, fly fishing is about where you go to use it. Most fish, btw, are caught at your feet - back to that stealth thing. I'll add that mid-length, mid-line-weight glass rods from the '70s fit best in water like just above.
-
Should I use my freshwater rod in saltwater
There's a major overlap between inshore gear and bass gear, anyway. 7' rods +/-, MH, ML, finesse... Some heavy bass rods are faster for specific niches, especially deep - inshore is usually no more than 3' deep.
-
Black and silver spinning reel
Here's my Twin Power 3000MHG with Yumeya spare spool installed (Exsense color) and Livre (Union) handle + balancer/hook-keeper. If you stick with Shimano and Daiwa, good aftermarket parts will let you make your reel custom, and look however you choose
-
Black and silver spinning reel
here's a Shimano Vanquish C2000S - JDM only, magnesium frame, titanium bail; parts matching and hand-tuning in Japan. It's the lowest-inertia spinning reel made. No crank start resistance, and the mechanism does not push your hand when you stop.
-
BFS Casting Reel - Your Line Choice
That's the thing if you have the cast reliability and can make the switch to braid, it moves the tackle into the next realm - 0.007" dia is 27-lb test in X-braid (PE#1.2)
-
Why Magnetic Braking System Than Centrifugal Braking On BFS reel?
@Tatulatard I know Major Craft makes spinning salt finesse (rockfish) rods - didn't know they made bait. Here's our normal use In addition to winter dock fishing, we use them for spring tide passes - targeting speckled trout, snook, and sight-fishing redfish. I have a shot coming this weekend. My buddy ended his first Major Craft UL rockfish (after 3 hard years) on the trip above (the solid tip split). He replaced with an upgrade to Yamaga Blanks BCIII-711 I still have two old Takamiya rockfish rods that have been at this 12+ years.
-
Why Magnetic Braking System Than Centrifugal Braking On BFS reel?
@Jigfishn10 This is definitely the way Japanese long salt finesse is heading - I wouldn't call progressive taper necessarily whippy, but 8'2" Yamaga blanks, 2-20-g range, is pretty flexy in the tip, long fast mid, stout butt. I wouldn't fish this rod from a kayak - it's a shore light game rod, perfect for docks and wading - you wouldn't want to fight a slot fish going under the boat. The biggest advantage this has is casting light plugs - they never foul, while casting on comparable spinning tackle, light plugs foul more often than not. Valleyhill makes a similar range of rods through MH - their bass BFS all range rods are definitely Fast tip, and 6'7". Here are two Valleyhill salt BFS rods, 7'2" and 7'6" https://fishingshop.kiwi/VALLEY-HILL-Cyphlist-HRX-Pro-Spec-Hard-Rock-Edition-CPRC-72LS-RFF/ - 1/16 to 3/8 oz https://fishingshop.kiwi/VALLEY-HILL-Cyphlist-HRX-Pro-Spec-Hard-Rock-Editione-CPRC-76MMS-RFF/ - 1/8 to 1/2 oz These are targeted for boat fishing. Note the bait versions have only been out a few years, but the Japanese have been fishing shore light game with rods like this for centuries.
-
Why Magnetic Braking System Than Centrifugal Braking On BFS reel?
I'll say it again. If Shimano had access to Daiwa's MagForce/SV patents, we wouldn't see centrifugal brakes at all. There's also a mistaken belief on this forum that what makes BFS is somehow a fad. What makes BFS is going to become the Norm in baitcasters - we already see the trend in Okuma Hakai, before that ZPI Alcance, and Shimano's use of magnesium baitcast spools. This is fast becoming the normal braid set-up for an MH baitcaster.
-
BFS Casting Reel - Your Line Choice
What @redmeansdistortion said - look there for AMO Official Store. Though from the wording of his question, sounds like he already found it.
-
I’m jonesing for a new rig for no good reason…
Ruling out BFS is missing out on casting Fun (with a capital F). Pocket rocket reels are a hoot, spinning is productive fishing, but BFS is FUN (and did I say fun?)
-
Rod company question
TackleDirect lists these four model lines - pretty much all offshore applications and inexpensive, especially for that niche. https://www.tackledirect.com/rods.html#/filter:manufacturer:Ande No mention of Fuji components, but aluminum oxide guide inserts.
-
BFS Casting Reel - Your Line Choice
Duel X-wire remains my favorite braid on baitcaster, I'm fishing down to PE#0.8 It's offered in 5-color that changes every 10 m, and silver with no marks. X-wire seems to have the same hard fluopolymer coating as Varivas High Grade, which I'm using on a spinning reel in PE#0.6. Yamatoyo Resin Sheller hardcoat in PE#1 is on my 4600 AMO spool, and fishes quite well, though the X-wire coating is more abrasion-resistant. Several of my friends are fishing 10-lb Sufix 832 with no complaints. BaitFinesseEmpire, btw, stocks a range of Varivas, including High Grade x8 in PE#0.6
-
Any value in vintage rods?
@Jhow Take them to this website https://reeltalk.orcaonline.org/index.php You'll find big salt reel collectors there, also vintage bass fishermen (who also use vintage gear), and vintage fly fishermen alike. Pflueger Supreme on American Fork & Hoe (later TrueTemper) square-section steel rod. Heddon #17 Black Beauty at work, matched with c. 1932 Heddon Little Rivers reel made by Shakespeare.