Which one catches more fish?

Two very different baits, but hands down for me,
the Trick worm catches more.

Now the Zoom Tiny Fluke, that catches everything.

Trick worm but the fluke is more fun to fish (IMO)

Only luck I've had with a fluke is pairing it with a fish head spin, but it's hard to keep the stripers/hybrids off it then.

For me it is the fluke.  I catch more on the fluke but that is probably because i fish it more often but really they both are about the same for me in weightless applications.  Weighted applications the trick worm produces more for me and that is usually how i fish them,

Fluke. Its not even close.

I would not vote against either one!

Both will catch you a mess of fish, and both can be fished in a variety of ways. You will be doing yourself a disservice if you didn't have these 2 baits in your tackle box. 

A weightless fluke is an bait with a truly amazing action, just looks irresistible. I have caught more fish on it than anything else once I discovered it. But I like trick worm, too, and have had success, for sure. I will fish it more now just to give it a chance, because I naturally grab a fluke on impulse by default because it is so effective.

If I could only take one bait with me it would be the trick worm

Worm by far for me. I keep trying the fluke but I must not be holding my rod right it's not catching fish like my other baits by a wide margin. 

I think the trick worm is more versatile.

I fish the fluke more often and catch more fish on it because of that but I think the trick worm will catch more fish. Its better at inactive and neutral fish and the fish are more often either one of those that active or in a state that they will react to a fluke.

Here in Florida both will catch scores of bass and it's honestly a confidence issue. I feel like I can fish a fluke more versatile and year-round than a trick worm. 

No contest the fluke wins on my waters. 

BTW, anyone who is not catching on weightless fluke... you may be fishing too fast. You don't have to fish it uber slow but just cast it, let it sink, and watch your line. One might run off with it. Then twitch and pause, twitch and pause until you get out of the cover (I throw at cover mostly) and then reel back and repeat to another target.

EDIT:  And there is another technique to fish it fast with twitches, but that is not my regular method.

worm  

Super fluke Jr hands down. It's one of my top 3 baits of all time. I've tried looking for substitutes but nothing comes close to its simplicity. 

5 hours ago, I.rar said:

Super fluke Jr hands down. It's one of my top 3 baits of all time. I've tried looking for substitutes but nothing comes close to its simplicity. 

How do you fish a fluke jr? What rod/reel and line and do you fish it weightless or not? Any particular color you like for the junior?

Ml/f st Croix avid x with a Sahara 1000 15# power pro and 6# floroclear leader. 

Weightless t rigged is how I usually go but you can c rig, split shot, drop shot, jig head and probably more that I'm forgetting. 

Baby bass is my first pick for the Jr. 

I've caught many more fish on the fluke but I have fished it a lot more.Lately I've started fishing the worm and done well with it.

From '96-'13 fluke ... 13-.. Trick worm ..