Skip to content

Who is your favorite all time quarterback?

Featured Replies

  • Super User

Peyton Manning? maybe if you were asking for the best crying

I guess you missed where it says "YOUR FAVORITE" in the title. I think he has started every regular season game in his career(162 games). How is he a crybaby?

Bart Starr - I just think that's about as cool a name as you could have.

Namath

Kelly

Simms

Elway

Montana

and recently added to the list: Manning, Eli not Peyton.

  • Author
Brady

Is he out for the season?

  • Super User

Yes, and he may not be able to play again.

He is one of the "Great Ones".

:(

  • Author

Oh wow. That's no good. Well, atleast for the team, Cassel looks pretty good.

Troy Aikman never complained and played hurt stats did not matter to him- played and started on a team that went 1-15 then went on to win 3 super bowls in 4 years.  Great accuracy and game management- If I could pick one out of any era to start for my team he would be it at quarterback.

  • Super User
Peyton is a great QB. He isn't a speedster, iron man, or tough guy...but he's a fairly decent QB.

So did you.

You're confusing me, do you like Peyton or not?  It's hard not to like a tactical genius like Mr. Manning.

Peyton Manning. He never misses a game, manages a game like no other, and he went to the University of Tennessee.

RW how on earth could you go and say something bad about the MAN? :-/

  • Super User
RW how on earth could you go and say something bad about the MAN? :-/

Marino played during the "Elway Era".

Most noteworthy stats:

Super Bowl Wins: -0-

Career Yards Rushing: 3

Marino played an extra year just to surpass records set by John Elway.

His accomplishments are squewd as a "one man team" dedicated to

the pass only. Elway, on the other hand, was a true leader, all around

athelete and team player.

8-)

Aikman here! GO COWBOYS!!!!

Since you asked for favorite and not best, I'll say Kurt Warner.

The guys was bagging groceries one year...winning the Super Bowl the next! And he played for my team!

To this day, there's nobody I root for harder than Kurt!!!

Bagging groceries?  I haven't heard that story.  Kurt was a quarterback in high school, played QB in college (at Norther Illinois), then immediately after college he played arena football (when he didn't get drafted), and then played in Europe's pro football league before finally getting drafted as a free agent.  I had to pull up wikipedia...after reading your post I thought he was some guy who worked at a grocery store and played football on weekends with his buddies before he was 'discovered'.  That would have been a better story I guess.  He still a great QB...

talent = Montana ( but a jerk )

Bradshaw = Superbowl rings

Ken Stabler to execute a drive

Bob Giese = gifted quarterback

For entertainment = Jim Mc Mahon ( def not for talent )

Len Dawson

Daryl Lamonica

Staubauch

Elway

Brady - best ever and a sixth round pick.  3 Super Bowl rings and played only one year with decent talent at wide reciever - and broke every passing record there was.

Regarding Marino, he went downhill faster than anyone ever seemed to point out. He was pretty awful for the last 3 or 4 years, and was closer to average for a good point of his career. That being said, he had a run when he was absolutely incredible. He always seemed to be yelling at his teammates too, not in a good way either. He'd fire a 100 mph screen pass at a no hands fullback 5 yards away and then chew him out when he couldn't make the catch.

Since you asked for favorite and not best, I'll say Kurt Warner.

The guys was bagging groceries one year...winning the Super Bowl the next! And he played for my team!

To this day, there's nobody I root for harder than Kurt!!!

Bagging groceries? I haven't heard that story. Kurt was a quarterback in high school, played QB in college (at Norther Illinois), then immediately after college he played arena football (when he didn't get drafted), and then played in Europe's pro football league before finally getting drafted as a free agent. I had to pull up wikipedia...after reading your post I thought he was some guy who worked at a grocery store and played football on weekends with his buddies before he was 'discovered'. That would have been a better story I guess. He still a great QB...

Here's the Kurt Warner grocery story from the Wikipedia entry on Hy-Vee...it wasn't the next year, but it's still a neat story.

"Two-time National Football League MVP Kurt Warner once stocked shelves at a Hy-Vee store in Cedar Falls, Iowa. After being cut by the Green Bay Packers at age 24, he thought his football career might be over and worked there to cover bills."

Donovan McNabb

Ron Jaworski

Randall Cunningham

Joe Montana

Brett Favre

Boomer Esiason

Tom Brady

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.