In clear water.

Watermelon Red or Green Pumpkin?

Green pumpkin all the way!

green pumpkin

+1 green pumpkin

Green pumpkin all the way!

x2

If the water had a greenish tint I'd opt for the watermelon red.

Green Pumpkin!!!!

Green Pumpkin for sure. At least in my neck of the woods.

watermelon seed

There are other colors besides green pumpkin?? Huh. 

In clear water, I would not opt for the darkest color.

Roger

clear to slightly stained: Watermelon

stained to muddy: Green Pumpkin

Green pumpkin cause its more more natural than watermelon red.

In clear water I'd pick watermelon red. If the waters really clear I'd pick an even lighter color though.

Watermelon Red Flake has taken the lion's share of fish for me on Ky Lake this year....and last year as well. 

Green pumpkin

i picked watermelon red because i like a more translucent colored green in clear water , more natural to me ....

Green Pumpkin

In clear water I'd pick watermelon red. If the waters are really clear, I'd pick an even lighter color

You betcha (Palinism).

In the crystal-clear phosphate pits of Florida,

the most popular colors are transparent silver, translucent white, translucent yellow & chartreuse.

Roger