Skip to content

Finesse, Baitcasters, Vs Standard

Featured Replies

  • Super User

On reading a lot of guys raving about the 50 size reels, over the last couple years. I purchased three.

Two Curado 50E'S, and a Chronarch 50e. After having used them enough to form an opinion, I have decided

that I prefer a full size reel. I love my Chronarch 200e's, My core 100mg's. It seems to me that the new Curado i's

fall somewhere in between in size, but I still prefer them to any of the 50's that I have used. Does anyone else

prefer full size over the small size. I am talking about for everyday use, not specifically finesse. The reason I ask

is because I know some of you guys use the 50's for everything.

 

Hootie

  • Global Moderator

I'm right there with you. I have a 50E that is a nice little reel, but it seems almost hard to palm. Maybe my hands are too big for it, I don't know. I still fish with a couple old Curado B's that are huge compared to a lot of reels today but I don't notice it I guess. 

  • Super User

I'm sure the size of your hand has a lot to do with how they feel.

For me the 50 is perfect, but I am not getting rid of my larger models.

 

 

 

 

:winter-146:

  • Author
  • Super User

I'm sure the size of your hand has a lot to do with how they feel.

For me the 50 is perfect, but I am not getting rid of my larger models.

:winter-146:

I hear ya. I wouldn't get rid of my 50's either. You just never know. Preferences can and have changed before.

Hootie

I prefer the smaller size for two reasons. I have small hands and the lower line capacity. I typically run small diameter 13 pound test, and see no need to spool up 200 yards of it. The 200 size casts and handles bigger baits better, but it's very rare I throw anything over half ounce. The 200 is to wide for me. I own 2 50s,everything else is Daiwa so I guess it doesn't really matter!!

  • Global Moderator

Never owned a 50.

Always thought about getting one but just couldn't justify it for what I do.

I always felt that a 200 can do whatever I will need it to do, but maybe a 50 couldn't do it as well...So I didn't.

Mike

I prefer smaller reels. I have huge hands and the core 50/51 is still the best palming reel ive ever used.

  • Super User

A wise woman once told me "That's why they make more than one flavor of ice cream" 

 

 

It is truly a beautiful thing that we can all find our comfort zone in this day & age, as there is no shortage of quality options.  There really is something for everyone, and there is no wrong answer if the reel fits your hand, wallet and situation.  It's a great time to be fishing!  Cheers to our first world problems!   :respect-059:  :Victory:  :drinking-10:

  • Author
  • Super User

A wise woman once told me "That's why they make more than one flavor of ice cream"

It is truly a beautiful thing that we can all find our comfort zone in this day & age, as there is no shortage of quality options. There really is something for everyone, and there is no wrong answer if the reel fits your hand, wallet and situation. It's a great time to be fishing! Cheers to our first world problems! :respect-059::Victory::drinking-10:

But ice cream will make the reel all sticky.

Hootie

  • Super User

But ice cream will make the reel all sticky.

Hootie

All the more reason to buy the coolest reel you can manage! ;)

  • Super User

 

It is truly a beautiful thing that we can all find our comfort zone in this day & age, as there is no shortage of quality options.

 

 

...unless you're looking for a 50 sized, left hand retrieve with a 5x : 1 ratio.

 

 

oe

  • Super User

I'm sure the size of your hand has a lot to do with how they feel.

For me the 50 is perfect, but I am not getting rid of my larger models.

 

This. The 50 is perfect for my hands, but I can 

totally get why it wouldn't be for folks with larger

hands.

 

In fact, the only reel I have in circulation that is 

"full size" is the Lexa, which is fine by me, though

not as perfect as the 50e.

 

My older Accurists are big and clunky by comparison.

I'm another one that loves the feel of the 50/51's in my hand. Since most of my fishing is ponds and out of my kayak focussed on shallow cover I don't have a huge need for a large line capacity. Having gotten used to the 50/51's, when I got the Chronarch Ci4 it felt a little larger than I would have liked. Once on the right rod it was fine, but definitely not what my brain was used to with the 50/51's.

  • Super User

On reading a lot of guys raving about the 50 size reels, over the last couple years. I purchased three.

Two Curado 50E'S, and a Chronarch 50e. After having used them enough to form an opinion, I have decided

that I prefer a full size reel. I love my Chronarch 200e's, My core 100mg's. It seems to me that the new Curado i's

fall somewhere in between in size, but I still prefer them to any of the 50's that I have used. Does anyone else

prefer full size over the small size. I am talking about for everyday use, not specifically finesse. The reason I ask

is because I know some of you guys use the 50's for everything.

 

Hootie

Better love that core because shimano has discontinued them.

I use both larger and smaller profile reels and decide on which one based on the size and type of bait I'm throwing, 'rght tool' mentality.  I have, however, eliminated round baitcasters from my bass fishing 

Where a lighter 50 sized spool shines for me is the ability to throw those lighter baits distances that would be hard or impossible to do with a bigger capacity reel.

  • Super User

I have one Calcutta 50 with a 5.0:1 gear ratio that I use for slow rolling spinner baits.

I absolutely love the way my 51e fits my hand. I picked up my 201e and it feels enormous in comparison. If I can't get a 50 sized BC, I'll go spinning.

For now anyways.

  • Super User

I don't consider the 50 size as finesse, just a smaller version that can do almost everything the 200 can.

I try and not be beholdant to any one size reel. Would I want to throw a 3/8 spinner bait on a 1000 size spinning reel or a 1/8 dropshot on a 200 casting reel? No, but I could do it. I try and match the weight and resistance of the lure to the rod and reel setup I use. Within these parameters there is overlap rather than specificity.

I bought a Curado 50E last spring and it is perfect for my "smaller" hands. Most comfy reel I have fished. A few months after that I came across a store that still had a few Curado's left so I snagged a 200E7. It feels ok but to me the 50 feels way better. I should have bought another 50 instead of the 200.

 

Just like most things....personal preference wins the day.

I bought a Curado 50E last spring and it is perfect for my "smaller" hands. Most comfy reel I have fished. A few months after that I came across a store that still had a few Curado's left so I snagged a 200E7. It feels ok but to me the 50 feels way better. I should have bought another 50 instead of the 200.

 

Just like most things....personal preference wins the day.

If you like the Curado 50 palming you will love the new Aldebaran 50s ergos even better.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.