This is pretty Funny

A-Jay (otherwise known as Gaffy Shortstick)

Red Fishin' Hole

Skinny Surfcaster.  Never surfcast and haven't been skinny in about 25-30 years. 

Lunky Bottomfisher

49 minutes ago, Brikon said:

Lunky Bottomfisher

Lunky Bottomfish #2!

Slick Fish Whisperer

Salty shortstick here. 

I'm Portagee Gone Wild. Quite ridiculous.

 This very Official name chart does make me quite thankful I didn't come into this world on May 18th . . .

A-Jay

10 minutes ago, Bass Turd said:

Slick Fish Whisperer

With your username you'd better be slick at something.   

Lunky Tunafish

4 hours ago, A-Jay said:

 This very Official name chart does make me quite thankful I didn't come into this world on May 18th . . .

A-Jay

Ajay, gaffy shortstick isn't exactly the best either..

Sharky surfcaster

Portagee Fishmore.....hey, I like it.

Capn' Sharkbait

Pluggy Greenhorn.  Appropriate. 

cap'n longcast……………..oh well.

Red fish whisperer!

gaffy surfcaster

14 hours ago, Ski213 said:

Salty shortstick here. 

Sorry to hear about that.

Slick Gone Wild, maybe you know my cousin Shooter McGavin.....

Sharky Mermaid Meat 

Gaffy Greenhorn

Sponge Bob Squarepants. I was conceived in a test tube.

6 hours ago, Gundog said:

Sorry to hear about that.

I feel like if this is a competition for the worst fisherman name I currently have a solid lead. 

My fishing name is "Skinny Seasick" but around these parts they call me Admiral Fussybottom!