Is this reel overspooled? Or does it look ok?

looks fine to me

id want more on there 

Looks a little under for a fresh spool but it will work okay. 

Looks perfect to me.

FM

7 minutes ago, casts_by_fly said:

Looks a little under for a fresh spool but it will work okay. 

I guess I didn’t put enough backing on

I have that reel in 1500 size and I agree you could have put a little more on.

If you notice the grove about 1/8" from the lip in the 2nd picture that is the full fill line on the spool. I usually fill right to the inside of the grove closest to the center of the spool.

It’s fine. I tend to underspool spinning reels a bit, it helps especially with slack line techniques when you’re reeling loose line onto the spool

Looks good to me. 

A little under, but not extremely so. I'd fill it to where the black and gold meet...or as Mr @Dwight Hottle stated...the groove.

I'd agree with the slightly under filled group....for freshly spooled.  Line size, type and stiffness would be the determining factor for any other type of line.