Wife: what kinda cake ya want for your birthday?

Me: pie!

 

Sweet potato pie & Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla!

@Catt my father and mother. 

Mom: What kind of pie do you want

Dad: Boston cream pie

 

Which sounds right but it’s not a pie, it’s sponge cake that has a cream filling and chocolate iced topping and takes twice the time to make . ?

I love any kind of cream pie, but my Mom's apple pie was the best.

On 12/17/2020 at 11:02 PM, Smells like fish said:

My family has a great peanut butter pie recipe, if anybody wants try it just let me know and I can post it. Personally I’ve never met a pie that I didn’t like ?

My family loves peanut butter pie.  It would be much appreciated if you would post it.  

So I decided to stay with the Christmas theme and will make an eggnog custard pie. 

Basically the same ingredients except some rum and bourbon.

 

I’m thinking of Bacardi Spiced Rum, but I think I need a consensus on the bourbon?

 

Any bourbon ideas here?

 

@jimmyjoe that pecan pie is on the radar!

On 12/17/2020 at 4:35 PM, jimmyjoe said:

    Pecan pie, vanilla ice cream and good coffee on the side, and I'm in heaven! ???    jj

 

 

Can't say it any better!!!

13 hours ago, Jigfishn10 said:

So I decided to stay with the Christmas theme and will make an eggnog custard pie. 

Basically the same ingredients except some rum and bourbon.

 

I’m thinking of Bacardi Spiced Rum, but I think I need a consensus on the bourbon?

 

Any bourbon ideas here?

 

@jimmyjoe that pecan pie is on the radar!

Any bourbon would work, most people keep cheap ones in the cooking cabinet and expensive ones in the drinking cabinet 

1/2 cup peanut butter

1- 8 oz cool whip (halved)

1- 8 oz cream cheese

1 cup confectionery sugar

1 graham cracker crust

 

Lay cream cheese out the night before, mix top 4 ingredients, saving half the cool whip for topping. Add a “splash” of milk if too thick. Edit: we always add milk. Add filling to pie shell and cover in cool whip and chill for 1-2 days before eating for best taste. 
 

@Terrance Waters 

Lemon Meringue pie is my all time favorite.

 

Just give me the dish and leave me alone.

1 hour ago, Smells like fish said:

chill for 1-2 days before eating for best taste. 

 

   I'll tell you one thing right now: if that there was sitting in my fridge, it definitely would not last 1-2 days.  It might not last 1-2 hours.   ?   jj

Mom sent me home with some derby pie today. It’s like pecan pie with chocolate chips and maybe a slightly different filling, not sure . It’s really d**ned good, that I am sure of