What have you had the best results with?

Plastic worms followed by plastic craws.

Roger

In no particular order spinnerbaits, plastic worms, and jigs have worked the best for me over the last few years. 

Plastic Craws, both Rage Tail and Paca Craws.

Jig.

Others:

Frogs

After frogs would be a wounded minnow crankbait, though i don't consider it a crankbait, and then rubber worms.

Crankbaits ;D

In no particular order spinnerbaits, plastic worms, and jigs have worked the best for me over the last few years.

Yep. Same here.

Plastics worms

I said plastics as well!

Senkos, jigs, baby brush hogs, beaver baits(BPS brand), 11" Zoom Magnum worms...

There seems to be a pattern here...

brush hogs, frogs, and cranks. cant pick just one, when one isnt working, one of the others more than likely will

I'm a plastic thrower, I have forced myself on the other stuff

This year was the year of the crank for me

Over the years, I've caught more fish on plastic worms than any other bait. However, I do like fishing with most other baits as well. Spinnerbaits, cranks, jigs, swimbaits and spoons. Oh plastic's to include craws, creatures, ect..Once you limit the bait you use, you limit you catch rate.

Hard choice between worms, spinnerbaits, and crankbaits.

   -gk

Give a Lucky Craft G-Splash and a cloudy day and I got more confidence than KVD and his Sexy Shad color.

5" senko  and 4" tubes

Plastics: worms, craw worms, creatures, and then lizards

Followed closely by Jig-N-Craws

Plastic worms have been best results and craws second

So overall most people who have responded have found rubberworms and other rubber products the most productive.

Rubber noplastic yes  

Overall, soft plastics have put the most fish in the boat for me throughout the years. This year crankbaits have overtaken soft plastics in my arsenal though jigs still play a prominent role as well. Though there are seasonal considerations etc. that play into lure selection as a general rule I choose baits that I can fish aggresively, cover water and try to generate reaction strikes. The crankbait excels in those categories. The last couple of years I have spent a lot of time on the water learning different brands/ models of cranks to get a feel for when to use a certain type of crank. I tend to use the 2 extremes the most, that is shallow runners over and ripping through weed flats and deep divers like a Norman DD 22 on deep points and outside weedlines. I have become a crank addict (is there a cure for this ? ) and I have a feeling there is no turning back.

I have caught all my biggest fish on soft plastic.My PB = 9.5 lbs was on a Zoom 6" cherry seed lizard.

worms for numbers and a buzzbait for size.