So about a month ago I was at a buddies smoking some Chuck roasts and I had my first ever cigar. I'm not a smoker by any means....I've had maybe a pack or two of cigarettes my entire life. That said I did enjoy having a cigar with some whiskey. So for you out there that enjoy the same what are some good mild cigars for occasional smokers? If they pair well with bourbon or rye that's a bonus.

For clarification the cigar I had was a deadwood sweet jane...im not sure if its flavored but it was extremely sweet to me.

I don’t drink any liquor at all so can’t help you there but the mildest cigar that goes with everything is a Macanudo 

 

I like the Cafe Hampton Court. 
It’s 5.5 inches long with a 42 ring size and comes sealed in a plastic tube which helps it keep its freshness if you don’t finish it in one sitting. 

If you want to try others look for one with a light shade wrapper. 
They are called Connecticut Shade with tobacco from the Dominican Republic. 
 

Darker wrapped cigars have tobacco from Cuba and Nicaragua which are much stronger. 

 

 

 

 

Mike

I’ve had two cigars in my life. Both were gifted to me. The first was from a friend who knows cigars well. He got me one he thought I would like for someone who doesn’t smoke. It was not a gas station cheap cigar. I absolutely loved it. It was a really nice smoke. I don’t know the name of it. The other was a cheap gas station cigar and I did not like it at all. So I decided if I’m going to ever buy a cigar for myself, I better choose wisely. 

5 hours ago, DitchPanda said:

So about a month ago I was at a buddies smoking some Chuck roasts and I had my first ever cigar. I'm not a smoker by any means....I've had maybe a pack or two of cigarettes my entire life. That said I did enjoy having a cigar with some whiskey. So for you out there that enjoy the same what are some good mild cigars for occasional smokers? If they pair well with bourbon or rye that's a bonus.

For clarification the cigar I had was a deadwood sweet jane...im not sure if its flavored but it was extremely sweet to me.

 

 

im about where you are.  My local buddies like them but it’s never been my thing. Never smoked a cigarette first hand. I’ll smoke a cigar once every couple months when they want them.  That said, acid blondies are something else. Super mild smoke and sweet on the lips. I could see keeping one around. 

Be prepared to spend some money. I got into the hobby when you could find seconds of good cigars for around a buck a piece. Those days are long gone.

 

I'll second Macanudo for mild. One of my favorites. If you liked the sweet cigar, Baccarat is old school sweet and extremely well made. 

 

 My personal favorite is La Gloria Cubana. It's fairly strong, though. Monte Cristo, Cohiba and H. Upmann are also good old brands. I wouldn't really know anything about the newer brands. The cigar boom hit awhile back and everyone and their brother wanted to start a cigar company or at least get their name on a stick. I lost interest in them at that time. 

 

What is a good lure for bass?

 

There is such a huge spectrum, I don't know what rabbit hole to start down.

 

A few considerations....

-Price: expect to pay $8-$20+ for singles in shops until you start buying boxes, and/or online discount stores and auctions.  This range is dependent on quality, brand, demand, and most importantly, your state taxes

- @Mike Lis correct that most lighter shade wrappers are milder.  Darker cigars can be somewhat mild, too, as the color comes from fermenting the leaves and that doesn't always equate to stronger. (Some brands actually dye the (outer) wrapper leaves for shelf appeal and uniform look, but that is not appreciated by most.

-The Acids mentioned above are infused with strong, non-tobacco flavors.  Some non-infused cigars have a tip that is sweetened.   Both are popular, but strongly cover up or disguise the actual tobacco flavor.

- I suggest that you go into a good cigar shop (not a vape/cigarette store) and tell the tobacconist what you can about what you have liked or disliked thus far and have them make suggestions.  There's thousands of options out there and every one tastes different. 

The only time I smoke cigars is when I’m fishing, started to keep the bugs at bay but now I just enjoy a long slow smoke. After trying quite a few I settled on the Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real in Corona size. The size affects how much smoke you get, thinner for less, fatter for more. A Get A Grip clip and cheap torch Lighter are a must when fishing. I prefer a punch to a cutter. 

 

I use one of the metal cigar tubes for transport in my tackle bag, you can get them to fit if you order a few of the Verona Tubo cigars (Same cigars, just in a tube), and recycle the tube.

 

Here in Ma, taxes are terrible on cigars, they can be had a lot cheaper on the internet.

 

I found ordering a couple each of several types, brands, and sizes a decent way to try different ones. The Macanudo Hampton Court is a mild one, you can also get them in. Tubo. I used to use the Golds when I fist started, just kind of a hassle to find.

 

 

I enjoy cigars while having a dram and sometimes while fishing. My approach to cigars and whiskey is the same, you're putting something that's not good for you, and may even kill you, into your body, so it better be good. I probably average $15 per cigar. Price doesn't  always equate to quality, but with cigars, you mostly get what you pay for. That being said, my line up revolves around:

 

1) My Father The Judge - this is my regular cigar, it's medium+ bodied to me, and I've had friends, new to cigars smoke it without issues. If you're new to cigars, get the robusto and just take your time, it will be a 60 minute smoke. The last 1/4 will be strong, consider skipping it.

2) Perdomo 30th Connecticut - I actually love the Maduro version of this, it's probably my #1 at the moment, but the Connecticut will be an amazing beginner cigar, I believe this averages around 15 year aged filler, it will be extremely smooth, creamy.

3) Oliva Serie V Melanio - This is a peppery cigar that pairs nicely with a rye. Again, if you're starting out get the robusto or even petite corona. I don't think it's as smooth as the ones above, but it has a lot of leather, wood, and pepper.

 

There are a lot of harder/expensive to get cigars, like Opus X and Rare Pinks, but don't chase those until you've developed your palate for cigars, much like whiskey.

Thank you all for the recommendations... Will be checking them out.

Ahhhh….the memories.  Good to see all the cigar answers.  I got heavy into cigars for a number of years, have a nice hand made humidor, and thoroughly enjoyed experimenting with different brands.  5 years ago when I retired I promised the wife I would give up my cigars.  Although she was talking about the small tins of Hoya De Monterey cigarillos I was smoking daily and not my full size humidor occasional smokes, I found it was easier if I just stopped altogether.  I had a small cigar shop here in my town where the owner, on the first Wednesday of every month would bring in hand rollers from a brand and would supply all the booze and snacks plus 2 hand rolled cigars for $20.  It was open to his regular customers.  I think we all started with Macanudos due to their mild flavor.  I really liked the taste but as they became popular, consistency faltered.  I got some great hand rolled sticks in the Dominican Republic on a trip there.  If you stick with the cigar hobby, you will find your taste will change over time.  Ultimately, I settled on Punch for the best flavor at the best price.  I’m sure the way taxes have been going the cigar market has been hit hard since I quit.  I’m tempted to give it another go.  I really did enjoy it.