Jeez, I haven’t fished a lizard in ages. I used green pumpkin when I did. This thread makes me wanna go out and try a lizard again. I’ll have to see if I still have any. Thanks OP!

Green Pumpkin with a little spike it 

I have thrown white when I sight fish beds. But I use 2 different colors otherwise. Carolina pumpkin/chartreuse and a BPS black light works most any other time. 

Green Pumpkin and Black with a blue tail. In clear water, cotton candy use to be pretty good but it's been a while since I have fished one. 

I use the following Zoom Lizards mostly
Black/Blue Tail

Junebug

Watermelon/Red Glitter

 

I also still have a big supply of the old Fliptail Lizard in black and will use this either weightless or Texas rigged. 

I don’t know the name of the color but it’s black with red flake. GP works in every pond ever created. 

6 hours ago, GReb said:

I don’t know the name of the color but it’s black with red flake. 

 

Black Neon 😉

Highly over looked color in any plastic 

 

 

Solid black

Solid white

GP

and a discontinued Madman color called Volcano. 

 

Allen

Missile D'Stroyer's Green Pumpkin Flash and Zoom's Pumpkin Chartreuse and Watermelon Slice.

Throw game hawgs more due to spots here biting the tails off lizards.  My go to colors are green pumpkin, pumpkin, black/blue, and a magnum zoom in straight black.  Also like the moccasin blue zoom lizard on one particular lake I frequent.

Usually for most soft plastics purple is my go to , but a guy who knows stuff at my home reservoir recommended I try a black lizard with a blue tail (Carolina rigged). I took his advice and wow I’m glad I did. 

I use the same colors for lizards as all other soft baits.

 

Stained water, tanic color--Black/Blue, Green pumpkin/Red, Junebug...I tend to use a black blue tail or black chart tail lizard the most. 

 

If clear water I go something natural-watermelons,gp....   I don't throw a lizard that often. I tend to find I can use a brush hog instead.