Seems like the vast majority of spinnerbaits are meant to imitate shad.

 

Unfortunately the area I usually fish doesn't seem to have any but has tons of bluegill.

 

Just lost my favorite bluegill spinnerbait and wanted to know if anyone has any suggestions for replacemes?

contact mike siebert @Siebert Outdoors and he'll hook you up with whatever color you want!  

Seibert has some excellent bluegill colors and great prices on his spinnerbaits. 

You can always buy bluegill colored skirts and replace your favorite brand. Seibert makes good one's as well.

I throw the Lucky Craft Skeet Reese one's in the bluegill pattern as well. A green pumpkin works as a good imitator as well, which I'm sure you have from sold old jigs. 

Check out Strike King's Premier Plus or Hack Attack.

http://www.siebertoutdoors.com/Spinnerbaits_c9.htm

 

I like this color pattern.

Aren't the famous Beetlespins good for this?

24 minutes ago, tcbass said:

Aren't the famous Beetlespins good for this?

LOL...yes. 

When I first read the title I thought of the same thing even though I knew he'd be looking for a bluegill colored skirt.

Get revenge!

Interesting, where I live there's no shad so spinnerbaits can't imitate something bass have never seen, some places have bluegills but not all, some have tilapia but not all, still my everyday spinnerbait color has been white and with it I have caught thousands of fish no matter where I went, Tamaulipas, Guanajuato, Jalisco, Nayarit, Queretaro, Sinaloa that old white spinnerbait has caused trouble.

H2o xpress sells a nice compact bluegill colored spinnerbait in bluegill colors. Ive had mine for a while and its caught me plenty bass

Misfit Fishing Co Spinnerbait

https://misfitfishingco.com/collections/handcrafted-fishing-lures/products/mfc-spinner-bait

Just buy yourself a few packs of skirts like the Terminator quick skirts, northland has their version as well and so does z-man. Then you can carry fewer spinnerbaits and just swap the skirts to change colors. My favorite bluegill color skirt comes from z-man 

13 hours ago, Raul said:

Interesting, where I live there's no shad so spinnerbaits can't imitate something bass have never seen, some places have bluegills but not all, some have tilapia but not all, still my everyday spinnerbait color has been white and with it I have caught thousands of fish no matter where I went, Tamaulipas, Guanajuato, Jalisco, Nayarit, Queretaro, Sinaloa that old white spinnerbait has caused trouble.

I'm with you Raul. Shad aren't common up north here, but sometimes it's more about what gives you confidence and not what the fish will bite. 

Pepper Custom Baits make the best spinnerbaits IMO, and they have several bluegill colors. Terminator has a bluegill colored skirt too.

Buy some bluegill colored skirts . I got theses at Cabelas  , on a hand poured bait . .

 

Looks blue gill to me ? Terminator 

 google Rocky Ledge spinnerbaits, in NH, he makes some nice compact versions. He probably has a website

The Strike King KVD Spinnerbaits - Tandem Willow Model: KVD38CW-234SG is aBluegill Spinnerbait.

Dirty Jigs Tackle Bluegill 2 Swim Jig Features a "3X Strong Jig Hook". Available in the weights of 1/4 oz. with a 4/0 Hook,... 5/16 oz, 3/8 oz, and 1/2 oz. with a 5/0 Hook.

Make your own skirts. Easy and fun to do in the winter.

 

North star custom baits makes a nice Bullgill and Newgill colored spinnerbait. So every also makes a nice one too.

On 10/24/2016 at 4:11 PM, Columbia Craw said:

I like this color pattern.

What brand is this spinner bait?

1 hour ago, ZMBasscat said:

What brand is this spinner bait?

Revenge. Not sure if still being sold

Love my bluegill 1/2 oz spinnerbait from Siebert Outdoors.  Those blades really thump and flash in a special way.